The case involved a dispute between the State of Haryana and Smt. Santra regarding medical negligence following a failed sterilisation operation. Smt. Santra, a poor labourer with seven children, underwent sterilisation in 1988, assured of its success. However, she later became pregnant, leading her to file a suit for damages amounting to Rs. 2 lakhs. The trial court awarded her Rs. 54,000, which was upheld by the lower appellate court. The State contested the findings, arguing that there was no negligence and that Smt. Santra had agreed not to claim damages if the operation failed. The courts found that the operation was incomplete, as only one Fallopian tube was operated on, which constituted negligence. The Supreme Court emphasized the duty of care owed by medical professionals and the State’s vicarious liability for their actions. It was noted that public policy in India supports family planning, and the failure of the sterilisation operation imposed an undue financial burden on Smt. Santra. The court ultimately dismissed the State’s appeal, affirming the award of damages to Smt. Santra for the costs associated with raising the unwanted child.
