The Court of Appeal has unanimously dismissed an appeal by a 27-year-old former religious teacher who sued the government and 32 others over alleged medical negligence in treating injuries he sustained in a road accident in 2020.
A three-member bench chaired by Justice Shahnaz Sulaiman, with Justices Nadzarin Wok Nordin and Amarjeet Singh, dismissed the appeal by Nabill Sajid Aslam Sajid after finding no reason to interfere in the High Court’s decision.
Shahnaz, who read the broad grounds of judgment, said the trial judge committed no appealable error in assessing the medical evidence and finding that the defendants acted in accordance with accepted medical practice.
The Court of Appeal ordered Nabill to pay RM30,000 in costs to the government.
The case arose from a road accident on July 11, 2020, in which he sustained multiple injuries, including an incomplete spinal cord injury, several spinal fractures, lung injuries and rib fractures.
He was admitted to Penang General Hospital’s intensive care unit and underwent spinal surgery on July 15, four days after the accident.
Nabill claimed that the delay in performing decompression surgery resulted in permanent tetraplegia, or paralysis in all four limbs.
He also alleged that the doctors failed to obtain proper informed consent and adequately explain the risks associated with the delay.
However, the defendants maintained that his medical condition, including his other traumatic injuries and haemodynamic instability, made immediate spinal surgery inadvisable.
They argued that the approach of prioritising stabilisation before performing definitive fixation surgery was medically appropriate.
The High Court dismissed the negligence claim, finding that the treatment provided was supported by a responsible body of medical opinion under the Bolam test, a legal principle used to assess whether a doctor’s treatment meets the accepted standard of medical practice.
The judge also found that Nabill had failed to establish the alleged negligence caused his permanent paralysis, which was attributable to the injuries sustained in the accident.
Despite dismissing the claim, the High Court assessed damages at RM4.14 million, representing the amount that would have been awarded had liability been established.
Nabill was represented by lawyers M Karuppanan and M Diveena, while senior federal counsel Afif Ali and federal counsel Amirul Hisyam Azedi Noor appeared for the government.
